Bizarre research article about parental confidence in GPs gets a mention in ABC’s Media Watch

Bizarre research article gets a mention in ABC’s Media Watch

In an earlier post I mentioned the bizarre article published by a paediatrician from the University of Melbourne.

The article concluded incorrectly that “confidence with GPs is an issue for parents of many walks of life”. The paper was rejected by the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (RACGP) and the Australian Medical Association (AMA).

The odd conclusions from the authors were reported by prime time media which in turn drew the attention of the ABC TV show Media Watch.

The article and subsequent reporting by some journalists attracted harsh criticism from presenter Paul Barry. And rightly so…

Bizarre research article about parental confidence in GPs gets a mention in ABC’s Media Watch

Media Watch sets the record straight: Most parents have confidence in their family GP. Source: Media Watch

The background

The authors reported the results of a survey about the confidence parents have in the paediatric care by Australian GPs. The survey was published in the Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health.

The findings showed that most parents are confident in their GP (only 2% of respondents was not very confident), yet the authors stated that “fewer than half of parents are completely confident in their GP to provide general care to their child (…).”

The authors conveniently omitted the ‘mostly confident’ category (45%) and only reported the ‘completely confident’ category (44%) as their main result. They then went on to conclude that this could potentially lead to “greater numbers of ED presentations for children with lower urgency conditions” and also suggested that GPs needed more paediatric training.

#trustaGP

Record set straight

The poor research quality coming from the University of Melbourne has raised eyebrows. GPs voiced concerns that, as a result of the paper and the incorrectly informed media coverage, some parents may take their sick children to the emergency department (ED) instead of the GP.

But ABC’s Media Watch has now set the record straight.

In a reply on this blog lead author Professor Gary Freed previously said: “If you do not like how we presented the results of this parent survey, for whatever reason, I respect that. However, I sincerely hope that does not result in you and others ignoring the underlying issue of worrisome changes in paediatric care and education among GPs.”

We now know that these ‘worrisome changes’ are not confirmed by the results of Professor Freed’s survey which clearly shows that most parents have no problem with the care provided by GPs.

View ABC’s Media Watch here.

3 thoughts on “Bizarre research article about parental confidence in GPs gets a mention in ABC’s Media Watch

  1. Very disappointing that this deliberate selection of the facts was published by a professor, paid handsomely from the public purse deliberately causing concern by many parents – just for a bit of attention. Publish or perish they say – the latter in this case.

    Like

  2. With all due respect, doctors are like every other professional, tradesman, teacher, etc, some are very good and some are not. I have recently moved to a new state and am still looking for a doctor who a) listens carefully, b) has more knowledge than I do, and c) gets the prognosis right and chooses the best way to treat it. I have known such doctors but they are few and far between. Make the patient the most important factor, not how many patients can be pushed through in the hours that the doctor is in attendance.

    Like

I'd love to hear from you! Please leave a comment:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s